CRL and Self-Help Laud Biden Administration and HUD Secretary Fudge for Proposed Rule to Stop Housing Discrimination Aug 25, 2021 WASHINGTON, D.C. – The Center for Responsible Lending (CRL), along with affiliated nonprofits, Self-Help Credit Union and Self-Help Federal Credit Union, today released a comment letter supporting a proposed rule from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to restore the “disparate impact” standard, a crucial legal tool used to identify and eliminate discrimination. Full text of the comment letter is linked here. “Discrimination continues to plague our housing market. It denies economic opportunities to Black and Latino communities and other communities of color, as well as women, people with disabilities, and the LGBTQ community,” said Aracely Panameño, Center for Responsible Lending Director of Latino Affairs. “The Biden Administration and HUD Secretary Marcia Fudge has proposed a rule that would bolster the fight against housing discrimination. It is our hope that this proposal will be finalized as written.” The proposed rule would, if finalized, rescind a harmful 2020 rule from HUD, which a judge has stayed. It would also reinstate HUD’s 2013 rule, which – as described in CRL’s comment letter – “better states Fair Housing Act jurisprudence and is more consistent with the Act’s remedial purposes.” Highlights of the comment letter from CRL, Self-Help Credit Union, and Self-Help Federal Credit Union: “It is critical that HUD proceed with reinstituting a meaningful disparate impact standard and vigorously enforce our nation’s fair housing laws.” “The 2013 Rule properly codified the disparate impact standard that has prevailed in the courts and has been used by regulators, including HUD, for decades.” “The 2020 Rule would have placed insurmountable barriers for a potential complainant to make it past the pleading stage when bringing a claim under disparate impact theory. HUD’s 2020 Rule also introduced confusing and harmful defenses, such as the ‘outcome prediction’ defense that would obfuscate discrimination in lender models and algorithmic systems. “The proposed rule appropriately returns the definition of ‘discriminatory effect’ that was eliminated by the 2020 Rule, including by acknowledging ‘perpetuation of segregation’ as a recognized type of discriminatory effect. The proposed rule also recodifies that actions that could predictably result in a disparate impact on a group of persons are prohibited by the Fair Housing Act.” “Today’s racial wealth gap and lending disparities are in large part the result of decades of government policies and practices that enabled the redlining of communities of color for most of the 20th century.” “While discrimination and its ill effects continue to the present day, much of it has become covert and harder to pinpoint. Disparate impact theory is intended to root out discriminatory policies and practices that are difficult (and sometimes impossible) to prove via a finding of intentional discrimination.” “Disparate impact, far from imposing excessive burdens and encouraging abusive litigation, has introduced needed innovation in mortgage and insurance markets, eliminating barriers to homeownership and encouraging more rigorous and accurate assessment of risk. Indeed, an analysis of ‘less discriminatory alternatives’ encourages innovation. It does not require lenders to ignore relevant and material underwriting criteria, but rather to avoid factors that disadvantage protected classes unnecessarily. “This disparate impact process… has resulted in a fair loan process for all borrowers and a more profitable one for banks. Some of those who historically have been denied loans at a disproportionate rate now have greater access. And not only have lenders fully retained their ability to identify and respond to risk, they have also expanded their customer base. This offers enormous potential to increase profit.” “For more than 45 years, disparate impact theory has been a crucial legal tool to fight discrimination and ensure equal housing opportunity. CRL, Self-Help Credit Union, and Self-Help Federal Credit Union strongly support HUD’s proposed rule to rescind the 2020 Rule and reinstate the 2013 Rule.” Additional Background The Fair Housing Act of 1968 prohibits the use of policies that seem neutral on their face but have an unjustified discriminatory effect. This stems from a recognition that this discrimination may not be as obvious as overt discrimination but is no less invidious. Courts have permitted disparate impact claims for over 45 years. In 2013, HUD, under President Obama, issued a strong disparate impact rule, grounded in decades of legal precedent. That rule was titled Implementation of the Fair Housing Act’s Discriminatory Effects Standard. In 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court affirmed the use of disparate impact under the Fair Housing Act in its ruling in Texas Dept. of Housing and Community Affairs v. Inclusive Communities Project, Inc. The Court made clear that disparate impact theory is necessary to fulfill “the Fair Housing Act’s continuing role in moving the nation toward a more integrated society.” Late last year, President Trump’s Administration issued a final rule, titled HUD’s Implementation of the Fair Housing Act’s Disparate Impact Standard, which would have decimated the disparate impact standard in housing. Civil rights groups and elected officials as well as mortgage industry leaders – including Bank of America, Citigroup, Quicken Loans, and the National Association of Realtors – urged the Administration to not issue the final rule. They expressed concern that the rule would facilitate housing discrimination and called for reexamination of the rule in light of ongoing national discussions around structural racism. This 2020 rule has been on hold, for now, due to a nationwide preliminary injunction issued by a federal judge. In January of this year, President Biden – as part of a wide-ranging agenda to advance racial equity – issued a memorandum acknowledging the federal government’s role in creating and perpetuating discriminatory housing policies, and directing HUD to reassess the Trump-era disparate impact rule. In June, the Biden Administration proposed its disparate impact rule, entitled Restoring HUD’s Discriminatory Effects Standard, to reinstate the power of the 2013 rule to halt and prevent housing discrimination. ### Press Contact: email@example.com 2020 News Releases 10/12/20 - Donnetta Collier is the new Financial Capabilities Coach for Self-Help Credit Union in Charlotte 09/18/20 - Self-Help Credit Union Awards 27k in Scholarships 07/17/20 - Seaway, a division of Self-Help Federal Credit Union and Guaranteed Rate, Inc.,. Partner to Expand Mortgage Loan Products To More Chicago Residents 6/12/20 - Self-Help Federal Credit Union names Rafael Morales as Senior Manager, Development Policy and Impact 06/04/20 - A Message from Self-Help CEO Martin Eakes to our Members, Partners and Communities 02/28/20 - Self-Help Credit Union Invests in Students Who Give Back to our Community 02/26/20 - Self-Help, NCC Development Initiative Partnership for Affordable Housing in Rocky Mount 02/05/20 - Self-Help Credit Union Announces Merger with First Legacy Community Credit Union 01/21/20 - Self-Help Credit Union Raleigh Branch Set To Open January 23 2019 News Releases 12/17/19 - Self-Help Credit Union Announces Merger with Turbine Federal Credit Union 11/04/19 - Free 'Know Your Rights' Event for People with Disabilities 10/14/19 - Self-Help Federal, Fresno, Grand Reopening 10/11/19 - Self-Help Credit Union is coming to Raleigh 09/19/19 - Affordable housing loan fund launches in Durham 08/13/19 - Trump Administration’s New “Public Charge” Rule Could Harm Low-Income Immigrants 07/29/19 - Self-Help Credit Union Announces 2019 Scholarship Winners 07/15/19 - Grand Opening Celebration Self-Help Credit Union, Charlotte 04/01/19 - Self-Help Offers Scholarships for Students Who Give Back To Our Community 03/27/19 - Imagine: the future of homegrown entrepreneurship 03/25/19 - March 30: Grand Opening, Angier Business and Children’s Center 02/11/19 - Self-Help Apopka Grand Opening Continues Legacy of Community Trust 02/11/19 - Free Disability Rights, Assistive Technology Event in Asheville, Feb 27 02/11/19 - Free Disability Rights, Assistive Technology Event in Morganton, Feb 26 01/31/19 - Black History, Black Entrepreneurship: Couple Launches Independent Pharmacy in Historic East Durham 01/24/19 - National Baptist Convention Embarks on National Campaign 01/14/19 - Self-Help Offers Hardship Loans to Furloughed Federal Employees 2018 News Releases 12/13/18 - New Video Explores Legacy of Bakersfield Credit Union First Founded by Cesar Chavez 09/25/18 - CommunityWorks Federal Credit Union Joins Self-Help To Benefit Members, CommunityTo Benefit Members, Community 08/24/18 - The MacArthur Foundation invests in Seaway, a division of Self-Help Federal Credit Union 08/07/18 - Newell Named President of Seaway, a Division of Self-Help Federal Credit Union 05/23/18 - Self-Help Credit Union, Mangum Street Grand Rededication (Durham) 2017 News Releases 09/19/17 - Self-Help Announces Third Annual "Bringing It Home" Conference in Asheville, NC 06/29/17 - In Senate Committee Hearing, CRL Lays Out Consumer Plan For GSE, Housing Finance Reform 06/13/17 - Florida’s Jax Metro Credit Union Merges with Self-Help Credit Union effective June 1 03/13/17 - Self-Help to Acquire Selected Branches of Former Seaway Bank in Chicago 2016 News Releases 09/13/16 - Family Federal Credit Union in Wilmington, CA Merges with Self-Help Federal Credit Union 07/13/16 - Self-Help Credit Union Announces 2016 Education Scholarships Winners 06/27/16 - Self-Help Announces DTC-eligible Term Certificates for SRI Investors 04/19/16 - Revolution Mill Media Event on Major New Tenant Thursday April 21, 8.30 am 04/14/16 - Self-Help Credit Union Announces 2016 Community Education Scholarships 04/13/16 - Self-Help Credit Union and Greater Piedmont Credit Union Announce Merger 03/10/16 - Lease Signing Ceremony Tuesday, 3pm March 14 between Renaissance Community Co-op and Self-Help 02/23/16 - Study: Self-Help “Fresh Start” Product Improves Credit Scores 02/03/16 - Florida’s Community Trust Federal Credit Union Merges with Self-Help Federal Credit Union 2015 News Releases 12/02/15 - CDFIs Craft3, Self-Help Complete Second On-Bill Repayment (OBR) Loan Sale 11/19/15 - Self-Help Credit Union Report: Racial Disparities in Marijuana Enforcement Undercut Durham Progress 11/17/15 - Grand Opening Thursday for Fresno’s Self-Help Federal Credit Union Branch 10/14/15 - Revolution Mill Hosting Media Tour Tuesday, October 20 at 10 am 10/01/15 - Self-Help’s Choice Community Credit Union Adopting Self-Help Credit Union Name 09/15/15 - National Cooperative Bank, Self-Help Federal Credit Union Team Up to Finance Los Angeles’ With Love Market & Café 09/14/15 - Self-Help Credit Union Hosts Brevard Branch Open House 08/24/15 - Self-Help Closes $4.6 Million Loan to Minneapolis’ Eastside Food Co-Op 08/17/15 - Statement on Julian Bond’s Passing by Self-Help CEO Martin Eakes 08/06/15 - Self-Help Credit Union “Adopt a Backpack” Drive Up and Running 07/28/15 - Self-Help Ventures Fund Ramps Up Construction On 45-Acre Revolution Mill SIte 07/14/15 - Self-Help Ventures Fund Ramps Up Construction on 45-Acre Revolution Mill Site 07/09/15 - Self-Help Credit Union Announces Education Scholarships Winners 06/11/15 - Renaissance Shops Groundbreaking Tuesday, June 16 at 10:30 am 04/09/15 - Durham Co-op Market Ribbon Cutting at 2pm Saturday 03/17/15 - Grocers on Wheels, Self-Help Credit Union Borrower, in Durham Today! 02/13/15 - Self-Help Credit Union Hosting New Economy Conference on March 18th About Self-Help Self-Help is a leading national community development financial institution headquartered in Durham, NC. Since 1980, Self-Help has provided over $8.5 billion in financing to 150,000 families, individuals and businesses. It helps drive economic development and strengthen communities by providing responsible financial services; lending to individuals, small businesses and nonprofits; developing real estate; and promoting fair financial practices across the nation. Through its credit union network, Self-Help serves over 150,000 people in California, Florida, Illinois, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, and Wisconsin. The nonprofit Center for Community Self-Help is the umbrella organization for the Self-Help family of nonprofit organizations, which includes Self-Help Credit Union, Self-Help Federal Credit Union, Self-Help Ventures Fund and the Center for Responsible Lending.